Knowby
Wacker Neuson – Plate Compactor or Rammer: Which to Use
Choosing between a plate compactor and a rammer: soil types, moisture, area limits, lift depth and number of passes, as explained by Wacker Neuson's product application and training specialist.
Choosing between a plate compactor and a rammer: soil types, moisture, area limits, lift depth and number of passes, as explained by Wacker Neuson's product application and training specialist.
1
Step 1 of 8

Know your soil type

The main difference between a plate compactor and a rammer is the soil type you are compacting.

  • Cohesive soils: clays, silty clays, very fine material

  • Mixed cohesive soils: a little granular soil with a lot more cohesive soil mixed in

  • Granular soils

2
Step 2 of 8

Match the machine to the soil

  • Granular soils: plate compactors work best.

  • Mixed and straight cohesive soils: rammers are the best product.

3
Step 3 of 8

Get the moisture right

Moisture is critical for proper soil compaction.

You cannot just add moisture to the surface of the material you are compacting: it takes hours to permeate through the lift.

Ideally the material is moistened before placement and then after compaction.

4
Step 4 of 8

Know the area limit for plates

A plate compactor, from the smallest to the largest, suits an area of roughly 5,000 sq ft (about 465 m²) of granular soil.

For anything over that, consider a smooth drum tandem roller, walk-behind or ride-on.

5
Step 5 of 8

Know the lift depth

  • Lighter plates (200 lb / 90 kg class): about 4 to 6 in (10 to 15 cm) of decent compaction

  • Heavier reversible plates: about 6 to 12 in (15 to 30 cm)

6
Step 6 of 8

Make enough passes

Wacker Neuson recommends a minimum of two passes. A pass is going one direction over the material you are compacting.

Two, three or four passes may be necessary to compact properly.

The machine tells you when it is done compacting: it bounces much higher than when it is still putting energy into the soil, and it has a different tone.

7
Step 7 of 8

Where rammers fit

Rammers are used with cohesive and mixed cohesive soils, typically in shallow, narrow trenches.

For anything over about 3 ft (0.9 m) and over about 15 to 20 ft (4.5 to 6 m) long, consider a trench roller.

8
Step 8 of 8

The critical elements

When deciding what type of equipment to use and how to use it properly, consider:

  • The machines

  • The soil type

  • The proper moisture content

  • The area, the lift depth and the number of passes